It used to be fun. It used to be challenging.
It used to be what you wanted to do with your life. But it isn't
anymore. Deadlines are getting harder to meet, fresh stories
harder to find and the long hours harder to endure. The money you
once thought didn't matter now does. And the stress you once
thrived on is getting harder and harder to cope
with.
Journalism. It was going to be your way
of changing the world. You soon discovered that wasn't part of
your job description. You could look, but you couldn't
touch.
Always on the outside looking in that
was the price you paid for the byline and the sign-off. But
neither makes up for the frustration, the disillusionment and the
stress anymore.
You've played Heat the Clock
for too long and now you're exhausted.
Look in
the mirror: you've become another statistic for the American
Institute of Stress. On the top-10 list of most stressful
occupations, the institute ranks journalism
seventh.
Decide now whether to hang in and hope
the byline blahs pass, or drop out before you burn out. As Sara
Procopio writes in "Dropping Out," it's a choice that has led
many journalists into the public relations field. But for others,
the thrill of chasing fire engines dies hard, and the price is
paid in ulcers, addictions and frustration. Caroline Butler
examines the symptoms and the solutions for those who have clung
to the fire truck ladder for too long in "BurningOut." The
Editors Dropping out.
"Look around," laughs
Eric Evans, vice-president and corporate secretary for Unicorp,
as he scans his dark woodpanelled penthouse suite. "Newspapers
don't have offices like this."
Evans, who is
now in his early 30s, was once a rising star at The Financial
Post. He was fascinated by business. So much, in fact, that it
soon replaced his fascination with journalism. He grew tired of
being a "voyeur," he says, "tired of always looking in the window
and reacting to what other people were doing. I wanted to be
causing things rather than reacting to them-and it didn't look
that hard."
After only four years at The Post
he began questioning his future. "I started asking myself, 'Where
will I be in five years?' There just didn't seem to be much
chance of advancement,"
Evans admits that he
thought about the money when making his decision to leave. "For
the first few years the money at The Post was pretty competitive
with those of my peers who had gone on to do other things, but
what was happening was I was starting to get left behind and I
knew I was going to get left way behind."
The
impediments to advancement, the triviality of some stories, and,
more importantly money, forces many journalists to leave the
profession. And many find themselves in the public relations
field. After all, the skills acquired and perfected during their
journalism careers, such as finding facts fast, handling pressure
and meeting deadlines, are essential in the communications
business. Journalists who decide the profession isn't what it
used to be find PR is an area where they can easily adapt their
skills,
Marjorie Wallens, once host and anchor
for Global's early morning news and public affairs program,
"Daybreak," turned to public relations when she decided to end
her 10-year career in television news. Wallens, now the director
of public affairs for the Toronto Transit Commission, earned her
bachelor of arts in journalism at the American University in
Washington D.C. in 1972. Shortly after, she came to Toronto,
"dying to be a journalist and wanting to be in television
news."
Her first job in Toronto was as a
freelancer with Citytv. In 1974 she joined Global to become
researcher and story editor for its business show, "Global Post."
Because of several financial reversals, Global was forced to let
her go. Her career took her to CJOH- TV in Ottawa as a reporter
then back to Global as parliamentary correspondent. Her career in
journalism ended in 1982 after "Daybreak."
"I
left the profession," she says, "because I started getting
restless and I started to see that the economic climate for news
and public affairs was changing. I could see down the road that
there wouldn't be a lot of money spent on new programming and so
I saw no opportunity for professional growth and
development."
Wallens started feeling that she,
like Evans, had been an observer for too long. "I wanted to be
more active," she says. After 10 years in the profession she
decided it was time to get out. "My whole professional career had
been consumed by the news business and I had no personal life to
speak of. It's a lot of commitment, and I was getting tired. I
started thinking that there was more to life than working around
the clock and what side Joe Clark parts his hair on. I saw it as
a young person's game."
"News papering is
definitely a young person's game. The hours, the lifestyle,
responsiveness and everything are for young people," says Anne
Moon, who is now directing the communications activities of the
Toronto health department. She graduated with a journalism
diploma from Ryerson Polytechnical Institute in 1961. She worked
for a series of newspapers including The Oakville Record Star and
the Hamilton Spectator before moving to Toronto with her husband
and landing a job with The Toronto Star in 1969. There she took
on the education beat and later was entertainment editor for
three years before finally becoming senior editor with page-one
responsibilities.
But, after 21 years in the
business, Moon left The Star. "I was going to be a writer from
the age of eight. It wasn't until I became senior editor that
this great flash of consciousness hit me,"she says. "I was having
a whole lot of ethical concerns about journalism, such as the
blowing up of trivia, the lack of attention to serious social
issues, especially at The Star," she recalls. Although she
accepts that newspapers have an important role to play, she also
feels they exploit people's misery.
Because of
these ethical concerns, Moon does not regret the decision she
made seven years ago. "The only regrets I have are when I see
idiotic mistakes in the paper which I know I wowd have caught had
I been there. Occasionally, I have regrets when there's a really
big story happening and I miss being part of the action and I
miss having the inside scoop. There was always that sort of
seductive feeling of being in the middle of
everything."
However, these regrets do not out
weigh the number of times when she, like other reporters who were
beaten by the system, found herself asking, "Why are we doing
this?" She says that too much time was spent on non-stories, "on
silly stories, stuff that wasn't put into the context of people's
lives." It was this feeling that convinced her she should leave
her chosen profession. She's not alone.
Bob
Purcell quit journalism for similar reasons. His first job was
reporting for the Vancouver Sun in the mid-sixties. He later
relocated to Toronto and worked for The Star as reporter, editor
and political writer. "I left the field in the mid-seventies
because what I considered the fun aspect of journalism was fading
fast. The newsroom camaraderie, the enthusiasm for valid and
prompt news coverage seemed to be less than it had been in
previous years," he explains. After 12 years, Purcell felt he had
had enough of being a "down and dirty journeyman" and sold his
sow to public relations. Today he occupies a comfortable office
as manager of corporate public relations for INCO
Limited.
"I was ready for something new and
different. The Star had been kind to me, giving me a myriad of
assignments but I had run out of new and different things to do
and decided I wanted to try private
enterprise.."
Feelings such as these,
unfortunately for the profession, lead some journalists to drop
out of their chosen careers and into more promising fields. For
others, however, the decision is one that is made for
them.
Stuart Allen was drinking in those days.
A lot. It took an ulcer and a failed marriage to make him realize
that he had a problem and needed professional help. That was 20
years ago. Now, after finding the right psychologist and three
years of "just talking," he's okay
again.
Today, the former CBC Radio producer has
found happiness in a new marriage and two new businesses: a
consulting firm and a production company. The scenario might not
have ended so happily. Allen could have ended up an alcoholic or
a drug addict, could have sunk into a deep depression or, like
four others he knew, could have killed
himself.
Instead, he learned to control the
stress and to accept his limitations. "When I realized I didn't
know it all,"
he recalls, "I stopped yelling, I
stopped screaming, I stopped, quite frankly, drinking as much as
I drank." He says that it's not easy for a journalist to accept
the fact that he does not know everything and that there are
things he cannot do. One thing Allen couldn't do was deny that he
had opinions. "One of the hardest things all of us have to learn
to deal with are those biases, those personal feelings," he says.
"It's impossible to go out and report on a story without becoming
personally involved with it, without having some kind of
conclusion which you may not put into print or broadcast on radio
and television."
Allen says that journalists
are expected to deal so dispassionately with events they cover
that they can forget they have emotions. He says this is just one
of the reasons journalism is such a stressful occupation. "That
kind of feeling you keep inside yourself, that kind of tension
builds up because you're writing a story about a group that you
might hate," he says. "A lot of people don't know how to deal
with it."
Therapy alleviated some of the
pressure and he became more honest with himself. "If I felt
strongly about something," he says, "I learned to speak up. If I
disagreed with something, I disagreed with it and I didn't hold
it inside."
Cindy Clegg was with CBC Radio for
13 years as reporter, senior news editor and producer. She finds
that one of the more stressful aspects of the field is its very
nature-objective reporting rather than active participation. She
says that journalists are "forever outside looking
in."
What makes this particularly hard, she
believes, is that the people drawn to this career are those who
want to change things, people who "care intensely about so many
things." Nevertheless, she says, "you are relegated to the role
of watching."
A career counsellor (who wishes
toremain anonymous because of client confidentiality) agrees. "I
think people go into this field with great expectations and with
high hopes and certainly a desire to change
something."
There are many other pressures on
journalists, notably the competition to get not just the story,
but the best story-on time. This kind of stress may sometimes
twist a reporter's ethical arm and consequently facts are
tampered with. CBS News, for example, was recently criticized for
faking footage from the Afghanistan war. Allen says that living
with the guilt that goes along with bending the truth puts an
even greater strain on journalists.
If bending
the truth carries a high penalty of conscience, the temptation to
lift someone else's words under pressure to produce can end
tragically. More than one lost job or lost life has been linked
to plagiarism. Ken Adachi's suicide last year followed a charge
that he had plagiarized in his Toronto Star column. Timothy
Pritchard, managing editor of The Globe and Mail, thinks
plagiarism is "an illness and a desperate calling for attention."
It's a symptom of a greater problem. Another threat to a
journalist's peace of mind is the hurry-up-and-wait syndrome.
Journalists often rush to an assignment just in time to sit
around for what seems like an eternity waiting for something-any
thing-to happen. Clegg remembers one assignment when she was
covering the Pope's visit to Fort Simpson, NWT. After days of
waiting the visit was cancelled due to fog. A small, unrelated
incident later that evening triggered tears. "I sobbed and sobbed
and sobbed," she says. Not because she was upset by missing the
Pope, but because she had been so worked up, only to be so let
down.
Clegg paid the price for her dedication
to a career in journalism-60-hour work weeks, stress-related
health problems and a divorce. But she doesn't place all the
blame on the business: "You can be your own worst enemy. I could
never walk away from a story."
Journalists are
"high-drive people and I think it's a self-selecting profession,"
says the career counsellor. Pritchard agrees. He says the nature
of the work appeals to the people who are temperamentally suited
for it. The stress acts as a drug for these people. Getting high
on deadlines might be what pushes them on.
But
sooner or later, this non-stop, one-sided life can get to be too
much. "It's very hard to be a
journalist,"
Clegg says, "and lead a balanced
life." Many have family problems because of the long hours, the
travelling and the unpredictable nature of the profession. Clegg
recalls rushing from the family dinner table to cover breaking
news.
Her desire to lead a balanced life led
Clegg to walk away from the CBC. Now she's the communications
advisor to Christine Hart, Ontario's minister of culture and
communications. She says she still works long, hard hours but
believes it was a good career move. She's participating and not
just watching. She realizes she can do more than write, and, "for
the first time in a long time, I'm learning
again."
Still, Clegg loves the thrill of
reporting. "It's exhilarating, but it's also demanding," she
says. "It's like hanging off the ladder on a fire truck. And how
many years can you do that?"
Today, journalists
on the verge of burning out have a safety net. Employee
Assistance Programs (EAP), which help staff deal with personal
and professional problems, have become more and more popular
among Canadian businesses. Though they have been around since the
1940s, their numbers have increased by 54 per cent since 1980.
EAPs are strictly confidential. In the case of the CBC, employees
call a Resource Centre line that puts them in touch with
counsellors. There's no intervention from
management.
The career counsellor finds
journalists open and sensitive in discussing their problems.
"When they've put their finger on the fact that they have a
problem," he says, "they want to find out what the truth is."
Psychologists, social workers and career counsellors are within
easy reach.
Along with stress management,
counsellors are trained to deal with alcoholism and drug abuse.
And even though journalism is changing, the image of the boozing
reporter is still not far from the truth. "The nature of
journalism is such that stresses are recurrent on a daily basis,"
says Martin Shain of the Addiction Research Foundation. Alcohol,
drugs, cigarettes and gambling too often provide an escape from
the daily grind.
But as more companies make an
Employee Assistance Program part of the modern newsroom,
journalists on the verge of burning out are more likely to
recognize the symptoms before they begin to feel like Clegg often
did: "like you're at the bottom of the bathtub and somebody's
pulled the plug."
Journalism. It was going to
be your way of changing the world. You had great expectations. A
desire to change something. But now it might have to be your
attitude. Even your job.