In June of this year, the seminal zine Punk Planet was forced to fold. A letter posted to its website declared Punk Planet's need to close (the reason being - what else? - money), and the eulogizing of the straightforward, socially-aware, independent punk culture publication began immediately. I guess it's my turn.
Unlike some others who are sad to have seen Punk Planet fold, I wasn't familiar with the publication for very long. Mine was a Toronto Life/Toronto Star house, and I grew up with the local Loblaws serving as the closest newsstand. Needless to say, Punk Planet wasn't kicking around on its shelves. At the same time, the number of publications featuring winged babies on paper apt to melt once met with the outside elements* was surprisingly low. Buried on the lower rack, though, between the bridal bibles and videogame magazines, were copies of Guitar World, some barely readable American hard rock mags and a few crunchy copies of Rolling Stone, unceremoniously crammed down to fit on the shelf. I already had a church basement meeting-worthy relationship with music, and I was initially inducted to the world of journalism by hotly contested lists of the top 300 songs about pie and Kirk Hammett's meticulous deconstructions of 30-second increments of every Metallica song, um, ever*. Born was the realization that there were indeed titles that offered my 12-year-old brain something to consume other than the fashion magazines and fluorescent, cut-and-paste teen entertainment rags being discovered by my peers.
A few years and more than a few trips beyond the grocery store created another church basement-worthy habit. Fangirling over Glassjaw in 2003 led me to an article by Jessica Hopper, a Punk Planet contributor. Hopper took it upon herself to call out emo, a subgenre of punk rock that had a comparatively small number of women participating, and tore into lyrics using violent imagery (the Glassjaw connection) and a first-person narrator who, Hopper claimed, put himself in a position where he was without blame for all the trauma he recounted. She rallied for more participation from women in playing music, for the self-actualization of women in the American punk scene. Although not necessarily Hopper's best work, it spoke to the music and the culture around it in a sharp, smart way. Hopper's piece conveyed a message without succumbing to self-righteousness and remaining accessible to those without an awareness of the references and language often relied on when discussing both gender politics and music.
With Jessica Hopper's little push, I became a reader. It was the first time I'd been able to relate to a publication that cared about more than Henry Rollins' tour rider, and on many levels, it was a welcome change to explore and understand the culture associated with music that appealed to me. When Punk Planet launched 13 years ago, punk culture was undergoing its greatest merge with mainstream popular music since its inception. Punk Planet was launched to preserve and continue what was originally important and embraced about punk culture. The magazine's content was often heavily influenced by both leftist and anarchist politics and traditional punk ideology. Punk Planet, which looked much like a perfect bound , commercial music mag, believed in independence, be that in letting their writers speak their minds, in refusing advertising from major record labels, or in their establishing of a literary publishing company where authors had the ability print and distribute their books without being connected to a major firm. They also emphasized the values of authenticity and encouraged questioning and outright objection. Just as in Hopper's article, printed nearly 10 years after the magazine's beginning, Punk Planet pointed out the problems and wasn't reluctant to consider solutions. For something widely considered a music magazine, Punk Planet had a unique approach.
In addition to serving as a reflection of a particular culture, Punk Planet also seemed to have strong journalistic intent and respect for its contributors. They were one of the first zines to pay writers ($50 for an interview, $100 for a feature), and provided information on their website about the kind of contributors they were always looking for. Regardless of how thick a portfolio or flashy a pitch you had, if your idea and approach were good, your piece had a chance of appearing in print. The zine went as far as offering a guide for contributors, condensing Reporting 101 into two-and-a-half pages on how to conduct a decent interview (and it's free...just sayin'). Writers were prompted to ask new, revealing questions in interviews, which often spanned up to 4 pages in the magazine. As for feature articles, Punk Planet made certain demands on its writers. A feature of 1,500 words didn't cut it, and they encouraged writers to seek out multiple points of view, something which isn't necessarily prioritized in existing music publications.
Punk Planet ultimately allowed readers to participate in punk culture through a media they could rely on to be thoughtful, consistent and broad in the range of subjects it covered, while sticking to its ideals in an environment that seemed to grow increasingly adverse. To some, Punk Planet will be remembered for covering serious issues in a manner absent from other zines and major-market media, while to others, it will be remembered as the only place that gave the time of day to their favorite band. Online publishing seems to be the inevitable solution to its demise, and at this point, all I can do is hope someone will find a way to live up to or surpass the standard of coverage developed by Punk Planet, but get lucky enough to do it as long.
Prepare yourselves, kids. Once Punk Planet's 80th edition is pulled off the shelves, the newsstand is going to look a little more the Loblaws of old. Maybe Tiger Beat would consider a do-it-yourself mohawk section, just to ease the transition a little.
-----------------
While on the subject of departures, I'm going to steal this public forum for a second to acknowledge the departure of Fred "aw shit" Mascherino from Taking Back Sunday this month. He's the only one in the world who can pull off Michael Jackson covers and Velcro, and I owe this guy a lot. Even though he's doing his awesome Color Fred thing, it's sad to see him go.
* No offence meant to Batboy or Kirk.